In defence of the Department of Divineguma:
Development under the proposed Divineguma Bill
Dr Vijitha NANAYAKKARA
A constructive dialogue on nationally important policies is
imperative in any liberal democracy. Raising opposing views, no matter
whether they are positive or negative in character opens up the
opportunity to emerge correct ideologies and notions which may lead to
good governance. The Divineguma Bill is being scrutinized these days as
an important national topic and anybody could constructively criticize
it with a view of making a positive contribution.
Setting up different departments, authorities and institutions
through which executive powers of the government are chanelled can be
made in any country based on felt needs and national interests. The
central role of any government is to identify national needs, set the
national development goals, formulate national development policies and
implement them with the consent of the people.
|
Home
gardens set to thrive |
Based on this objective, the Divineguma Bill proposes to amalgamate a
number of organizations, namely the Samurdhi Authority of Sri Lanka, the
Udarata Development Authority of Sri Lanka, the Southern Development
Authority of Sri Lanka, the Department of Peasant Rehabilitation and the
Samurdhi Commissioner General’s Department. It is intended to create a
just and fair society through the process of development and alleviating
poverty.
The institutions cited above come under the purview of the Ministry
of Economic Development and they were set up with the view of
accelerating economic development of the country, particularly improving
the living conditions of the economically disadvantaged across the
country. Multiple institutions operating separately with similar goals
and objectives in many third world countries including Sri Lanka seem to
create situations where duplication or even triplication of development
activities may occur at the same time.
Poverty alleviating programmes
Employing a large number of officers for the same task in similar
organizations wastes money and much needed resources of the country.
This can be seen not only in the government sector, but in the
non-governmental sector as well. Repeating the same activity in a
selected village by different non-governmental organizations may lead to
waste the limited resources available for disposal.
It is estimated that approximately 10 percent to 20 percent waste of
resources is likely in many poverty alleviating programmes and
development projects in the third world. Given the circumstances, it is
time to amalgamate institutions with similar goals and objectives on a
carefully crafted plan for a common goal. The development priorities are
not static and they are subject to change from time to time. It is
essentially a dynamic process so that institutional frameworks need to
be reformulated to fit into the changing needs of society.
The Samurdhi Authority is the biggest organization which is going to
be amalgamated with other similar institutions under the Divineguma
Bill. The work force of the Samurdhi Authority alone far exceeds 25,000
at present. This authority has been functioning over the last 15 years
and when the Samurdhi Authority was first established in 1995, the
percentage of families living with poverty was in the range of 25
percent to 30 percent, which is currently around 7 percent.
According to new millennium development goals, we will have to
achieve the target of 13 percent families living with poverty by 2015.
Surprisingly enough, we have already achieved this target by recording 7
percent by 2012. However, programmes should be put in place to absorb
people who are coming out of poverty to contribute to the national
development through strategically designed development plans. Therefore,
it is time to reformulate the role played by the Samurdhi Authority over
the years to reflect the current needs of the country.
The Divineguma Bill literally aims at establishing a separate
department named the Department of Divineguma Development (hereafter
DDD) to fulfill the tasks cited above. The national policies should be
reformulated with the view of strengthening people’s hands through
various income generating economic activities, not encouraging food
subsidies or food rations so that people will have every confidence in
making their own living. The ultimate aim of the DDD is to create a
situation where people can stand up on their own feet, leaving aside the
dependent mentality on food subsidies forever.
Changes in development programs, approaches and policies are vital
and they need to be adjusted to fit into the international experiences.
With the collapse of the International Financial Market in 2008/2009,
changes in new liberal economic policies were advocated by many
including international development organizations. When reviewing the
American economic history, it is also clear that certain economic
protection strategies were used to protect and strengthen the domestic
economy. Countries such as South Korea and Singapore made drastic
changes in their new liberal economic policies in recent years.
The role of the government in the pursuit of economic development is
determined by the specific condition of the country. Currently, many
international development organizations and some western think tanks
raise the issues of ‘human rights’ ‘transparency’ ‘integrity’ and ‘good
governance’ but surprisingly, the application of these concepts seems to
be different in the developed countries from the third world. The
questions need to be asked about the loyalty of some intellectuals who
are not prepared to question the ‘transparency’ and ‘integrity’ of these
western organizations who maintain double-standards when it comes to
practice.
Development strategies
We need to prepare ourselves to discard some ‘Western’ ideologies,
and disregard some Western expertise and consultancies made by ‘Western’
think tanks and instead, focus on domestic development strategies. We
need to be brave enough to identify domestic needs and formulate novel
development strategies to fulfill these domestic developments goals. It
is our own right to set up institutional structures and policy
frameworks to reflect current needs of the country together with certain
structural changes within the organizations.
|
Self-sufficiency through cottage industries |
The clientele of the DDD under the Divineguma Bill is the socially
and the economically disadvantaged across the country. This group of
people have so far been denied any opportunity to involve in national
development projects. It is essential to secure their contribution to
national economy through a proper development approach at grass root
level. Through such an approach, the empowerment of the rural poor, and
capacity building are vitally important.
Participatory development approach has been in place in many
countries for a number of years and it seemed to be very effective in
achieving certain development goals particularly in the rural context.
This bill proposes to follow this approach whenever needed in our rural
development program. It is clear therefore that the structure of the DDD
is formed around community based organizations and these organizations
are directly linked to the DDD. Moreover, it will be a new experience in
the history of government departments to mobilize human resources for
meaningful national development through the encouragement of financial
savings, and creating micro level financial networks for investment
projects.
The Department of Divineguma Development is not merely a bureaucratic
organization where executive powers chanelled through the top to the
bottom but an organization where peoples’ participation is ensured from
the bottom to the top. Creating an institutional framework to maintain
the right balance between the departmental structure and the structure
of the community organizations is the most important aspect of this
department. Maintaining the balance between the supervision and
monitoring by the department and the supervision and monitoring by
community organizations create a situation where transparency of many
development projects can be properly ensured.
Regional political authority
While the functions of any department established in a ministry span
across the country serving all citizens, its actions would not interfere
with the regional political authority and the existing institutional
framework at regional level. The aims, objectives, powers and functions
of the proposed department of Divineguma development have been clearly
specified in the Divineguma Bill.
The improvement of the main livelihood of people, families and groups
is the main objective of the proposed department. The bill has clearly
identified the necessary actions required for fulfillment of this main
objective of the department. Nevertheless, powers and functions of other
departments are not included in the proposed bill.
The government has established many departments and the scope of
these departments has been identified to serve the entire population.
Accordingly, all departments are functioning to fulfill a common
objective of the nation. The gap between two departments is not like a
definite boundary between two plots of land. The improvement of nation’s
education by the department of education is conducive to uplift the
economic conditions of the country.
Electricity needed for nation’s schools should be provided by another
department so that the collaboration between different departments is
vital for the overall functioning of modern nation states. Mutual
collaboration among different departments and other institutions of the
state does not necessarily mean that they do interfere with the
activities of other departments or institutions.
It is therefore very difficult to ascertain how the functions of the
DDD affect other departments as may be the case that how does the
provision of electricity supply affect other departments or how do the
functions of the Police Department affect other departments and the list
goes on. The important point to consider, leaving aside such a painful
scrutiny is to work together to fulfill the common objectives of the
government, collaborating with all departmental authorities and
institutions across the country.
The DDD is not an institution set up for executive administrative
functions nor does it conflict with powers and functions of any regional
administrative apparatus established under the 13th amendment to the
constitution. Poverty alleviation is essential for rural and regional
development and the projects aiming at alleviating poverty do not affect
the powers and functions of regional institutions under the 13th
amendment. The goals, powers and functions of the DDD have been clearly
set up in a way that they are not in conflict with the goals, powers and
functions of other regional institutions.
Community organizations
Some critics highlight that the proposed department may intervene to
the existing administrative structure by operating its project
activities establishing new project administrative Zones under deputy
directors. Creating a number of administrative zones under the DDD to
ease the administrative problems would not affect the existing, normal
administrative set up of the country.
For example, the MOH divisions in the Department of Health or
education zones in the Education Department have been set up beyond the
administrative boundaries of the divisional secretaries (AGA divisions)
for the smooth delivery of services of each department. It does not
affect the general administration of the country. Therefore, it is not
wrong to establish administrative zoning within the proposed department
for its administrative purposes.
A critique against the Divineguma Bill pointing the attempt of
expanding the power of the minister is baseless. It is within the powers
vested in the minister to enact regulations and give orders to the heads
of the departments of any ministry. In order to fulfill the objectives
of any bill, it is essential to have necessary powers vested in the
minister to enact regulations and to pass orders. For example, it is
possible to establish community based organization under the proposed
bill, but the details of the ordinance or constitutional frameworks for
these community organizations are not seen in the bill.
The details of constitutional frameworks will be presented in
supplementary regulations that will be put in place in future by the
minister. The selection criteria for Divineguma beneficiaries will
change over time. If the criteria is presented in the bill, it will be
difficult to pick up the changing needs of the beneficiaries that may
occur over time and in a situation of this sort, an amendment to the
bill will have to be presented to the parliament to change the criteria.
Therefore, as may be the case in other bills, it is acceptable to have
necessary powers vested in the minister to enact new rules and
regulations, if and when required.
Community based organizations would be able to function independently
but when they are assigned to implement government projects or use
government funds, they are inevitably subject to supervision and
monitoring by the department. It is necessary to monitor all department
projects to see whether things are heading in the right direction,
particularly to maintain the financial discipline of all projects.
All projects will be audited by government auditors so that the
department needs some kind of authority over supervision and monitoring.
Through strict monitoring and supervision, it is expected that the
government funds will be effectively and properly utilized for
socio-economic development of the country. The Divineguma Development
Fund (DDF) is a departmental fund which will be established by the
minister under clause 35(1) of Divineguma Bill. As the head the
department, the subject/line minister should have the power and
authority to oversee the smooth functioning of the fund. There is no
room for any misappropriation of the DDF since all financial dealings
associated with the fund are subject to the government auditing.
Micro-financial banking networks
With the powers vested in the DDD, it is expected to conduct
lotteries with the assistance of the National Lotteries Board to boost
the DDF. It is a common practice of many departments, authorities,
institution etc to conduct lotteries in order to fund certain projects.
Previously, under the Samurdhi Act, a lottery was conducted by the
Samurdhi Authority. By the same token, the Sevana lottery was introduced
by the Premadasa administration for housing development.
It is expected to minimize the inequality of income distribution
through various poverty alleviating projects. It is also totally
justifiable to conduct a Divineguma Lottery by the DDD to strengthen the
Divineguma Fund. There would not be any hindrance to conduct and
maintain similar lotteries for the benefit of the above fund.
The main objective of the Divineguma Community Based Banks is to
create micro-financial banking networks at regional level. It is the
Divineguma beneficiaries who save money in these community banks, and
receive benefits as well. It is important to note that these Divineguma
Community Banks are not commercial banks in the conventional sense and
only those who are members of Divineguma Community Based Organizations
are eligible to use them.
The target group of these banks or the main clientele are those who
are excluded from conventional commercial banks for a number of reasons.
Individual or group based loans will be available for those who are
disadvantaged by numerous rules and regulations of commercial banks.
Under the Divineguma Bill, the DDD is empowered to establish these
non-commercial rural banks with the purpose of providing much needed
banking facilities for the rural poor in particular.
It was the same policy under which the Samurdhi Banks were
established in the 1990s. After the discussion with the Central Bank of
Sri Lanka, it was agreed that the regulations and clauses of the Banking
Act in 1988, No 30 and 2D11, No 42 under the Financial Enterprises Act
would not affect the Divineguma Community Banks. However, these
micro-financial banking network will be monitored and supervised by a
committee of eminent people including the representatives from the
Ministry of Finance and the Central Bank, director of the Divineguma
Community Banks, and the Director-General of DDD. Thus, financial
activities will also be audited by the government auditors. It is
essential to have a community banking system of this nature for the
benefit of rural people who are marginalized by the ‘big banks’.
It can be noticed that some politicians criticize the sentences in
the Bill regarding the confidentiality of the information pointing out
the fact that such practice will challenge the rights of the people to
reach the truth. The officials of the DDD are responsible for
safeguarding the confidentiality and anonymity of the information on
their clients.
Apart from judicial proceedings, it is the ethical requirement of the
department to protect the identity of individuals and to safeguard the
confidentiality of information on clients. There are some ethical
constraints in any department in releasing the internal information and
the officials cannot expose and release any personal information without
the consent of the client.
However, it is alleged that some non-governmental organizations are
involved in scandalous financial dealings with the rural poor using
their photographs and personal information. Under the Divineguma Bill,
restrictions will be imposed on collecting personal information from the
poor and selling them for financial gains. At the same time, the
information collector who collects personal information is liable to
safeguard and maintain the confidentiality of all personal information.
The DDD should also be exemplary in this regard.
This does not affect the transparency of the department and there is
no obstacle whatsoever to question and test the transparency of
activities of the department. After all, the Divineguma Bill is aimed at
establishing a brand new department which caters for its staff, and
beneficiaries. It is a new experience in the history of Sri Lankan
departments and we see the making of a good department through this
bill. You are encouraged to generate a citizens’ voice of concerns
around the Divineguma Bill through a new approach which is neither
traditional nor completely alien to the Sri Lankan context. We are still
confined to a ‘box’ which is either ‘traditional ideologically driven’
or ‘Western ideologically driven’.
It is disappointing to see that even some Western trained
‘intellectuals’ are not in a position or not prepared to think beyond
this ‘box’ and create a viable institutional framework which is truly
Sri Lankan. I truly believe that the Divineguma Bill aiming at
establishing the DDD will make a great contribution to alleviate rural
poverty and uplift the living conditions of rural masses of this
country.
|