Has begging got out of hand?
The word ‘Begging’ is generally linked with pleading or ‘demanding’,
particularly money. Generally beggars appear on the streets. Begging is
also referred to as ‘Panhandling’.
Apart from the common type of street begging in public, there are
more advanced and sophisticated methods adopted today in a somewhat
glorified manner. Internet begging, cyber-begging, or Internet
panhandling is the ‘online version’ of traditional begging, seeking
money to meet numerous needs. This type of supplication has a clear
advantage over face-to-face street panhandling because of its ability to
eliminate the shame or the apparent disgrace practised incognito.
Cyber-begging became evident, in the form of personal advertisements,
during early phase of the internet with personal web sites becoming
popular and individuals taking advantage of the features available
therein. ISPs (Internet Service Providers) offering free home pages with
a basic dial up connection service to the internet helped many
desperados ‘to make hay while the sun shone’. For some fraudulent
organizations who managed to raise funds ingeniously from snail mail,
the World Wide Web offered a more elaborate from by utilising the new
found internet techniques.
Google exposes how ‘the Internet Begging’ gained notoriety and
momentum after June 2002 quoting Karyn Bosnak’s website,
‘SaveKaryn.com’, where ‘she was alleged to have used the Internet to
seek public assistance to pay off her credit card debts’.
|
Beggar
using an IPhone in Colombo |
Begging letters are another form of foul play where rich individuals
are approached with prayerful letters, usually when lottery winners are
exposed publicly. Such letters written by someone can also reach an
organization claiming to be ‘poor ‘and seeking help with a variety of
human needs to very humorous.
Spiritual dimention
‘Nigerian 419 scam’ is an example of begging letters where 419
communications were sent to wealthy persons asking for financial
assistance for orphaned children, emergency surgery, etc. The May 1850
edition of Household Words contained an article entitled The
Begging-Letter Writer, noted down by Charles Dickens. In the article
Dickens described examples of the many begging letters he received over
the years and the ploys adopted by writers to gain funds.
Apart from a vast array of practices of begging, a different
dimension takes place with many religious orders to mendicant way of
life. ‘In the Catholic Church, followers of Saint Francis of Assisi and
Saint Dominic became known as mendicants, as they would beg for food
while they preached to the villagers’. In traditional Christianity rich
are encouraged to serve the poor. In many Hindu traditions, spiritual
seekers begging for food is regarded as a materialistic distraction from
the search for Moksha (spiritual liberation). Begging, they believe,
promotes humility and gratitude, not only towards those who give food,
but towards the Universe in general. Dervishes of Islam makes Zakat
(similar to a wealth tax) which is compulsory for every Muslim during
one’s life time and another type of charity which is open ended to one’s
heart’s content. It is also found in the monastic orders of Buddhism
called Pindapatha. In every such case meritorious deed and generosity of
contributors seem naturally to fulfill another dimension of their
spiritual self-advancement ‘to seek’ a better spiritual station after
death.
Modern tactics
A fast growing practice in Sri Lanka is ‘visiting beggars’ seeking
financial support with an array of beseeching. Poverty and destituteness
is a different kettle of fish altogether as long as it is credible, but
should those who with compassionate hearts become suckers to such
tricksters who seem to take one’s sincerity as a weakness?
The other side of the coin is that every human being is born with a
certain amount of self-respect. No one would like to stoop to a
degrading level of humiliating by visiting house to house if they are
able to manage their livelihoods, in the absence of a well designed
social security system.
In such a backdrop how can people identify a bona-fide case unless a
beseecher is known personally? In a world of fraudsters and tricksters
who are hell-bent on making a quick buck by hook or by crook, at the
expense of the sympathetic folk it becomes very difficult to trust
anyone at present times.
This issue has become very complex in Sri Lanka. The moment one gets
out of the house or opens the door or keeps the front gate open, beggars
of different kind keep on approaching. When a vehicle comes to a stop at
red traffic light signals what do we come across? Beggars bombarding
you!
Certain type of ‘begging’ families have turned imploring as a
profession for generations to accumulate sizable wealth by ‘employing’
other newer beggars. These groups claim to have marked territories and,
if unknown beggars approach such areas it might end up in verbal and/or
physical abuse.
Some advise the general public not to give a cent to beggars who come
across on a daily basis as they are ‘supposed to be employees’ of big
villains behind, who make use of destitute people to spin money. Here
the ‘employer’ is supposed to drop men and women at various allocated
points and collect them in the evening giving them a percentage of day’s
return as their commission or daily wage!
‘Aggressive panhandling’ generally involves solicitation of donations
in an intimidating or intrusive manner especially from foreign tourists
where individuals are seen following foreigners in a Pied Piper fashion
and not taking ‘NO’ for an answer. In certain cases supplicating can be
in a loud voice often accompanied with wild gesticulations and use of
insults, curse or veiled threats.
Sophistication has become the term to be used with beggars in this
technological age. The attached email picture shows a beggar outside the
Colombo Town Hall engaged in his routine business........ doing what?
Have a good look ... ...... Using an IPhone! Who is taking whom for a
ride.....?
[email protected]
|