The devious self-righteousness of Bobby Rae
Prof. Rajiva WIJESINHA
Bobby Rae
|
The last couple of weeks have seen much attention to Sri Lanka on the
part of politicians in the Western world. This attention is based on
what they claim to be concern for suffering civilians in the North, and
such concern is welcome.
However, it would have been more convincing, and thus more effective,
had it not followed on months of neglect, and had it not been
accompanied by gross misrepresentations of the situation.
Typical of what amounts to mistaken indulgence of terrorism were the
sanctimonious pronouncement of Bobby Rae, a former provincial Premier I
believe in Canada, and now what is described as ‘foreign affairs critic
for the Liberal party’.
Army personnel providing relief to civilians |
Rae also has some experience of Sri Lanka, dating from the Ceasefire
period, since as he puts ‘As chairman of the Forum of Federations, I
attended most of the negotiating sessions of the so-called peace talks,
and met with the leaders of Government, opposition, civil society and
the LTTE, known as the Tamil Tigers. I have been back many times since.’
Rae then goes on to lay the blame for the current problems foursquare
of what he calls the ‘Sinhalese community - the majority population’
which he claims ‘took power after the departure of the British in 1949
and over a long period made a series of disastrous decisions’.
He has obviously failed to realize that Sri Lanka had a constitution
bestowed by the British which, as in Britain, gave political power to
those who won elections.
The main Tamil party held office in the first three governments, and
there were Tamil ministers even during the period of greatest violence
against Tamils, namely during the government of President J R
Jayewardene.
Rae fails to note that the policies of several governments also led
to violent agitation by Sinhalese youngsters. He does not record that
the declaration that Sinhala be the only official language of the
country was remedied in 1987, after the Indo-Lankan Accord, which was
opposed by the Tigers alone amongst Tamil political or terrorist
organizations.
Rae does record that the ‘Tigers were ruthless at killing their
opponents in the community’ and that they ‘use suicide bombers against
civilians and recruit children into their army’, but he promptly goes on
to claim some sort of justification for them in terms of their ‘support
around the world’.
He privileges this by talking about ‘the sense of the Tamil people
that they have never been able to find justice inside a failed state’ as
though to uphold himself the idea that Sri Lanka is a failed state.
Negotiations
Then, while claiming that this ‘does not justify or excuse suicide
bombings and the recruitment of children’, he does precisely that by
suggesting that those who oppose the Tigers make the claim that “they’re
terrorists and that explains everything”.
Rae says that this latter claim is inadequate, and of course it is,
which is why it is stupid of him to make it as though it were made by
others.
The Sri Lankan Government has consistently made it clear that, while
it had even been prepared to talk to terrorists, and did so over several
years, continuing terrorism and the rejection of negotiations could not
be tolerated.
It is precisely because Tiger terrorism is something apart from the
political question that the Government has continued negotiations with
non-terrorist Tamils (whom Rae ignores, perhaps believing that they have
now all been killed by the Tigers, since he well knew the Sri Lankan
Tamil Foreign Minister Lakshman Kadirgarmar who was murdered back in
2005 when the Tigers still claimed to be adhering to the Ceasefire
Agreement).
Rae indeed is totally disingenuous in his depiction of what happened
during the peace talks. He claims that ‘even during the peace talks it
was impossible to get the Government to lay out a new approach to
governance that is essential to get to a durable peace’.
This is a total lie, and Rae knows it. Obsessed as he is with
federalism, he must know that the Wickremesinghe Government thought a
breakthrough had been made when the Tiger delegation agreed in 2002 to
base discussions on a Federal model; and he must know that it was the
Tiger leader who went back on that agreement and then unilaterally
withdrew from talks in 2003.
But Rae, in what can only be described as disgusting sleight of hand,
simply refers to the ‘collapse of the peace talks in 2003’ without
saying who walked out.
He ignores the fact that the present Government managed to persuade
the Tigers to finally come back to talks in 2006, only to find them walk
out again, and meanwhile launch two massive offensives against
Government forces whilst still claiming to be adhering to the Ceasefire
Agreement.
He knows well that the Scandinavian monitors found the Tigers guilty
of nearly 4,000 violations of the CFA, the Government guilty of less
than a tenth of that number. He knows that the Tigers continued to
recruit children during this period, and tried to persuade the Norwegian
facilitators not to allow this to figure on the agenda of the talks.
He knows that the Tigers were buying and bringing in arms throughout
the CFA period, even blowing up a ship on which the monitors had
discovered arms, with risk of life and limb to the poor Scandinavians
who had found the secret compartment in which arms were hidden.
Bob Rae is not a fool. So many lies and half truths cannot be
attributed to folly in a former Provincial Premier. What then is he
trying to achieve?
Something of what he wants is clear when he talks about the Sri
Lankan military tightening ‘its noose on what had been officially
recognized as ‘Tamil territory’ during the ceasefire’.
The man may not understand English, but even he must realize firstly
that the agreement referred to areas under LTTE control, and secondly
that the terms LTTE and Tamil are not synonymous.
There can be no question in Sri Lanka of ‘Tamil territory’ or
‘Sinhalese territory’, because the whole land belongs to all its people
- as the Tamils well know, over half their number living in the seven of
the nine provinces that are majority Sinhalese.
He also says that something should be done for the ‘300,000 Tamils
trapped in the northeast’, without mentioning that they are trapped
there by the LTTE. The Sri Lankan Government is horrified that no one
cared about these people for six months and more, and that there was no
support for its call to the LTTE to let these people go.
The UN, the NGOs, knew very well that the LTTE was not allowing those
who wanted to to leave, but even when people trying to get away were
shot, there was no squeak from anyone.
The UN justified its silence on the grounds that it was concerned
about its workers and their families who were amongst those forcibly
kept back, but it realized that this silence would lead nowhere when
attempts to bring them out with a recent convoy failed even though they
had been led to believe that egress would be permitted.
Rae ignores this, and with the ebullience of Little Jack Horner
pulling out a plum he declares that these ‘hundreds of thousands are not
terrorists’. Does he not understand that this is what the Sri Lankan
Government has been pointing out for months?
Does he not appreciate that this is why the Government continued to
send in food and provide education and health facilities for these our
people, to the extent that the UN Resident Coordinator remarked after
the last UN monitoring visit that Sri Lankan officials in these two
departments deserved a prize?
Rae must know that even the LTTE cadres have survived thus long on
the food we have been sending in. Rae knows perfectly well that at least
some of the ‘support’ the Tigers enjoy internationally is due to
intimidation and extortion. Rae knows that pronouncements such as his
only give strength to a terrorist movement that would otherwise be
destroyed.
Independence
Rae is most welcome to speak on behalf of Tamils, and he should also
welcome the approach of the first Government since independence to
specifically recruit Tamils to the police, to introduce regulations with
regard to the need for officials to be bilingual, to promote durable
solutions to the many Sri Lankans expelled from the North by the Tigers
when they engaged in ethnic cleansing there and drove out the Muslims.
None of this may mean much to Rae, swept away by his dream of
federalism, with himself as the arbiter of all excellence. But it is the
lives of people he is playing with, and he really should grow up and
learn to deal in truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth.
The writer is Secretary General, Secretariat for Coordinating the
Peace Process.
|