No 'over-reaction' to Final farce says ICC chief
WORLD CUP: Officials whose error led to the farcical finish in the
World Cup Final do still have a future in cricket, according to Malcolm
Speed.
The International Cricket Council chief executive said the five-man
playing control team led by match referee Jeff Crowe were full of regret
for their roles in the bizarre spectacle that saw Australia 'twice' win
a record-breaking third straight title and left losers Sri Lanka having
to bat out the closing overs in darkness on a Kensington Oval ground
with no floodlights.
Somehow a group featuring West Indian umpire Steve Bucknor, standing
in a record fifth World Cup Final, managed to overlook a basic playing
condition for one-day internationals.
This states that once 20 overs have been bowled in both innings
enough cricket has been played to have a result declared under the
Duckworth/Lewis system for rain-affected games.
Instead the teams, following instructions from Bucknor and Pakistan's
Aleem Dar, the other on-field umpire, came back on Saturday to bowl
three more overs in a match Australia then won by 53 runs under the D/L
system.
Speed, who came through a moment of farce himself when an ICC
backdrop almost fell on him as he spoke during a news conference at
Kensington Oval here Sunday, indicated Bucknor, Dar, third umpire Rudi
Koertzen, reserve official Billy Bowden and Crowe wouldn't face
immediate censure.
"They certainly do have a future in the game," said Speed. "We are
not going to over-react to this. The umpires and Jeff Crowe, they had
earned the right to umpire in the World Cup Final because they are
outstanding umpires and an outstanding referee.
"I saw Jeff Crowe this (Sunday) morning, he came up to me and said 'I
am very sorry about yesterday (Saturday), we are all very sorry about
yesterday, it shouldn't have happened'," the Australian added.
Speed said it was wrong to compare the events on Saturday with those
that took place at The Oval in August last year where England won a Test
after Pakistan were ruled to have forfeited the game - the first time
this has happened in Test history - after refusing to take the field in
protest at being penalised five runs for ball-tampering.
That sparked a sequence of events that led to experienced Australian
umpire Darrell Hair, whom Pakistan believed to be the prime mover in
enforcing the penalty, being barred from officiating in major
international matches. Hair is now taking legal action against the ICC
and his case is due to be heard by an employment tribunal in London
starting in October.
"After that issue at The Oval there was a very comprehensive review
of all the match officials who'd been involved in that incident. We will
go through a similar process here," Speed said.
"But to put the two together, I think it's drawing a long bow and
unfair to these five officials who were involved in the incident
yesterday (Saturday)."
BARBADOS, AFP |