![](BuddhistSpectrum.jpg)
Death seizes the doting man
The doting man with mind-set on
children and herds, death seizes and carries away, as a great flood
sweeps away a slumbering village.
- Magga Vagga - The Dhammapada
Emotions as seen in Buddhism and modern science
Lionel WIJESIRI
EMOTIONS: Western science teaches that genetic makeup,
environment, and external experiences influences the brain, which in
turn creates emotions and leads to thoughts.
From the Buddhist view, thoughts influence emotions, which in turn
affect behaviour and brain functions. Most rational thinkers today
believe that the scientific view is disempowering because by emphasizing
external factors, there seemed little the individual could do to
influence his emotions and thoughts.
![](z_p18-bud1.jpg)
Kapilawastu: The return to Kapilawastu.Sandstone.1st Century
B.C.Sanchi, India. |
They find the Buddhist view more acceptable because it seemed that we
could do something to help ourselves.
From a scientific viewpoint, an emotion has three aspects:
physiological, feeling, and behavioural. Brain activity and hormonal
changes are physiological, and aggressive or passive actions are
behavioural.
In Buddhism, emotions refer to the mental state. Little is said of
the physiological changes, probably because the scientific instruments
for measuring them were not available in ancient India.
Buddhism also distinguishes between the emotion of anger and the
physical or verbal action of being assertive, which may or may not be
motivated by anger. Similarly, someone may be patient inside, but have
either assertive or passive behaviour, depending on the situation.
Buddhists and scientists also differ on what is considered a
destructive emotion. For example, scientists say that sadness, disgust,
and fear are negative emotions in the sense that they are unpleasant to
experience.
However, from a Buddhism viewpoint, two types of sadness, disgust,
and fear are discussed. One is based on distortion, interferes with
liberation, and is to be abandoned, for example, sadness at the break-up
of a romantic relationship and fear of losing our job.
Another type of sadness helps us on the path. For example, when the
prospect of having one rebirth after another in samsara makes us sad and
even fills us with disgust and fear, they are positive because they
prompt us to generate the determination to be free from cyclic existence
and attain liberation.
Such sadness, disgust, and fear are positive because they are based
on wisdom and stimulate us to practice and gain realizations of the
path.
Science says all emotions are natural and that emotions become
destructive only when they are expressed in an inappropriate way or time
or to an inappropriate person or degree.
For example, it is normal to experience sadness when someone dies,
but a depressed person is sad in an inappropriate situation or to an
inappropriate degree. Inappropriate physical and verbal displays of
emotions need to be changed, but emotional reactions, such as anger, are
not bad in themselves.
Therapy is aimed more at changing the external expression of the
emotions than the internal experience of them. Buddhism, on the other
hand, believes that destructive emotions themselves are obstacles and
need to be eliminated to have happiness.
Many scientists believe that from the viewpoint of evolutionary
biology, anger enables human beings to destroy their foes, and thus stay
alive and reproduce.
Another type is associated with a constructive impulse to remove an
obstacle.
For example, if one faces a situation where he cannot get what he
wants, his anger makes him think how to get it. It is being called
"positive" on basis of its effect - the person getting what he wants -
not its being virtuous.
In addition, such anger does not always lead to a solution of the
problem. For example, frustration and anger due to our inability to
concentrate when meditating rather than help us attain calm abiding,
block our practice.
Buddhism does not agree that there is a positive form of anger.
Although in a secular way, anger at someone who is harming himself or
others could be called "positive," arahats are free of this.
Thus, righteous anger is a defilement to be eliminated to attain
nirvana. We can have compassion for the person and still try to stop his
harmful behaviour. Thus, while the West values moral outrage as an
emotion, from a Buddhist viewpoint, it is skilful means, a behaviour
motivated by compassion.
Most of us when things are going well would much rather focus on
happiness than dwell on the sufferings of the world.
But reality has a nasty habit of intruding. Love turns to heartbreak,
wealth to poverty, health to sickness, peace to war, life to death. We
are shocked and hurt to discover that things that once seemed so real
and solid turn out to have been mere illusions.
It may be a personal tragedy that brings us to this realisation, or a
national or global disaster. We feel helpless and confused, at a loss as
to how to deal with our own and others' suffering. It is then that we
seek answers.
Why did this happen? Was it my fault? Can I prevent it happening
again? By addressing such questions, Buddhism offers an explanation for
how our sufferings arise and a path by which we may transcend them.
Buddhists view the world we perceive as an illusion, in which
everything is subject to change, growth and decay in accordance with the
law of cause and effect, or karma.
Buddhists depict the workings of this cyclical existence as a wheel
showing the chain of events leading from thought to action and its
consequences.
At the hub, three "creatures" represent greed, anger and ignorance,
the driving forces that keep the wheel in motion, condemning us to an
endless cycle of suffering.
If we can eliminate these forces by applying the antidotes of
compassion and wisdom, the cycle is broken.
Theory is all very well, but can this model help us come to terms
with the sufferings we encounter individually or as a society? It can
certainly serve as a tool to remind us that since we are the creators of
our own suffering, we also hold the potential for our deliverance.
An anthology of discourses from the Pali Canon reflecting the
edifice of the Buddha's teachings
N.T.S.A. SENADEERA
IN the Buddha's Words: An Anthology of Discourses from the
Pali Canon. Edited and introduced by Ven. Bhikkhu Bodhi. Boston: Wisdom
Publications, 2005. 485 pages. Price (at BPS, Kandy): Rs. 875.00.
An anthology: In the Buddha's Words is a landmark anthology of
discourses of the Buddha by Ven. Bhikkhu Bodhi. It brings together
selected discourses from the Pali Canon in order to reflect the overall
structure of the teachings of the Buddha by way of a clear scheme.
![](z_p18-bud2.jpg)
Translations from a wide variety of discourses-164 in all-culled from
all over the Pali Canon have been arranged into 10 chapters for this
purpose.
Ven. Bodhi mostly uses his own translations from the Pali, but he
also used some translations of other translators, modifying them in
order to fit his general scheme of translation.
Ven. Bodhi realized the urgent need for a structured anthology of
discourses from the Pali Canon when he was teaching a course on the
Majjhima Nikaya in his monastery in the USA.
According to Venerable Bodhi, the volume is intended for two types of
readers: "The first are those not yet acquainted with the Buddha's
discourses who feel the need for a systematic introduction. For such
readers, any of the Nik yas is bound to appear opaque.
All four of them, viewed at once, may seem like a jungle-entangling
and bewildering, full of unknown beasts-or like a great ocean-vast
tumultuous, and forbidding... The second type of readers for whom this
book is meant are those already acquainted with the suttas, who still
cannot see how they fit together into an intelligible whole.
For such readers, individual suttas may be comprehensible in
themselves, but the texts in their totality appear like pieces of a
jigsaw puzzle."
Ven. Bodhi hopes that (1) this volume will serve the newcomers to
early Buddhist literature as a map to help them wend their way through
the jungle of the suttas or as a sturdy ship to carry them across the
ocean of the Dhamma whetting their appetite for more and encouraging
them to plunge into the full Nik yas and (2) the volume will assist the
experienced readers of the Nik yas to obtain a better understanding of
the material with which they are already familiar.
Since the discourses in the Pali Canon are not arranged either in any
chronological or subject-based sequence, and there is no single
discourse in which the Buddha draws together all the elements of his
teaching and assigns them a place within an comprehensive scheme, one
cannot obtain a overall view of the structure of the Buddha's teachings
just by reading and studying a few discourses.
Even for those who have the capacity to study the discourses in
detail, it can sometimes be difficult without a scheme to figure out
where a specific discourse or discourses fits in the extensive framework
of the Buddha's teachings.
It is therefore a praiseworthy endeavor on the part of Bhikkhu Bodhi
to have developed such a comprehensive yet accessible scheme that
reflects the overall architecture of Buddha's teachings.
Ven. Bhikkhu Bodhi mentions that his scheme may be original, but it
is not sheer innovation as it is based upon a threefold distinction that
the Pali Commentaries make, indicating the types of benefits to which
the practice of Dhamma leads.
These benefits are (1) welfare and happiness visible in this present
life; (2) welfare and happiness pertaining to future lives; and (3) the
ultimate good, Nibbana (Skt. Nirv na).
Three preliminary chapters-the first one on the basic human condition
of suffering in samsara, the second on the Buddha's appearance into this
world, and the third on the special pragmatic and non esoteric features
of the Buddha's teaching-lead up to the seven chapters embodying the
three benefits scheme.
These start with a chapter revealing the Buddha's ample teachings on
social harmony and peace-the welfare and happiness visible in the
present life-that comes from living in accordance with ethical norms in
one's relationships, livelihood, and communal activities.
The fifth chapter is on how one can attain happiness in the next life
through the accumulation of merit based on generosity (dana), virtue (sla),
and meditation (bhavana).
The next chapter is showing that, though the Dhamma leads to
happiness in this life and the next, even a pleasant life is dependent
on impermanent conditions and will finally end in death.
The Buddha's teaching is therefore concerned with leading one beyond
conditioned and impermanent mundane happiness to the supreme happiness
of the Unconditioned, Nibbana-the ultimate type of benefit.
The final four chapters give a general overview of the Path to the
Unconditioned, the gradual mastering of the mind through calm and
insight meditation, the development of higher wisdom with the aim of
attaining the Unconditioned, and the stages of realization transforming
the individual from an ignorant worlding into a Liberated One who has
fully realized the Unconditioned.
The anthology aptly concludes with a few suttas on the supreme
qualities of the Buddha and his great power of illuminating the dark
world of ignorance.
The value of his anthology is greatly enhanced by the general
introduction and by the introductions at the beginning of each chapter.
These introductions provide the mortar required to build the edifice
of the Buddha's teachings, presenting a careful analysis of the
teachings and helping the reader to fit the components of "the jigsaw
puzzle" into their appropriate places.
The Dalai Lama's foreword shows how much the different schools of
Buddhism fundamentally have in common.
In the Buddha's Words bears evidence again of Ven. Bhikkhu Bodhi's
penetrative and analytical understanding of the Dhamma and his great
ability in explaining Buddhist philosophical issues to modern readers.
Ven. Bhikkhu Bodhi, born in New York City in 1944, needs no
introduction in the Buddhist world. His excellent translations of
Buddhist discourses and his profound and illuminating expositions of
Dhamma are in constant use across the world.
Moreover, he is the editor of many books on Theravada Buddhism
published by the Buddhist Publication Society in Kandy, of which he is
the president.
It is well known that theistic religions have lost their hold in the
minds of many educated persons in the modern world and that this has
created a deep spiritual vacuum that needs to be filled.
Therefore, compiling an anthology of discourses from the Pali Canon
that provides a comprehensive and schematic representation of the
Buddha's teachings is quite relevant.
Following the footsteps of Ven. Nyanaponika Thera, the main teacher
of Ven. Bodhi, who played an important role in shaping the expression of
Theravada Buddhism in the latter half of the twentieth century, Ven.
Bodhi continues the important mission of shaping the expression of
Theravada Buddhism in the first half of the twenty-first century.
Readers in Sri Lanka can obtain this important work from the Buddhist
Publication Society in Kandy (http://www.bps.lk) at less than half the
U.S.A. sales price.
Love is lost in lust
E.M.G. EDIRISINGHE
LOVE: There are some individuals who say that "Love is not
Lust" and others have to come out to say that love and lust are two
different things and love is a sweet relationship between two
individuals. Amor vincit omnia is another version we are familiar with.
All these misconceptions or misinterpretation are due to either
misuse of words or being unaware of using the right word to give light
to the envisaged point of expression.
In this instance what the Buddha preached is useful and relevant to
the layman who is making an effort to understand the nature and meaning
of love.
The Buddha says Pematho Jayathi Soko (love begets sorrow). Whatever
form love takes whether maternal, paternal, fraternal or patriotism, it
eventually ends in sorrow.
So, any sweet feelings of love towards each other is impregnated with
reciprocity, and certainly that ends in sorrow after passing through
various stages of hatred, jealousy, enmity and uncertainty.
On the contrary, what is not so is Meththa (loving kindness) and
Karuna (compassion), two principal tenets in Buddhism.
Meththa is show of loving kindness to living beings as a whole, and
karuna means compassion extended to everyone as individuals.
In both these instances, the receiver as well as the giver are
spiritually and materially enriched and that never ends in sorrow or
involves hatred whatsoever at the beginning or at the end. So, what we
need today is not really love; we have plenty of it, but meththa and
karuna.
So, leaving aside the question whether love is lustful or amorous,
whether one is a believer or not, an atheist or a free-thinker, what we
all should practise is meththa and karuna.
Then this world will be free of hatred and jealously and all the
people will begin to live with true mutual brotherly feelings, wherever
they live or whatever they believe in.
When the Bamyan Buddha Statues were destroyed, the Buddhists in
general showed sympathy to those ignorant men who destroyed those
spiritual and cultural master pieces.
Similarly, when cartoon pictures of the Prophet were published, we
must show sympathy for such narrow-minded people because their intention
is to arouse anger in the followers. If they succeed they have won.
Howevermuch one tries to insult the Buddha or the Prophet, nothing
will happen to their images as long as the followers or the adherents
are convinced what was preached or revealed is true and guides them for
a better life.
The Buddha once said that there is not a single person who had not
been insulted during his lifetime or after. That is the truth the Buddha
found. It covers everyone and everything like all components are
subjected to change
(Sabbe sankhara anicca). |