Police structures and professionalism
The
Indian journalist Sathiyamoorthy, one of the sharpest – and also I think
most sympathetic - commentators on the Sri Lankan scene, wrote recently
on questions in connection with the army and the police in the North.
With regard to the latter, he seems to be of the view that the police
should not come under the Ministry of Defence, which is not an argument
I accept.
My main reason for this is the very simple belief – on the basis of a
principle known as Occam’s Razor – that one should not create entities
unnecessarily. Unfortunately Occam’s Razor is unknown in Sri Lanka,
where we multiply entities endlessly, as with Ministries and layers of
government. In affirming the need to keep the police under the Ministry
of Defence I believe we should also extend the principle more widely,
but that is another question, and requires more thought and strength of
mind than is usually applied in this country.
Sathiyamoorthy thinks a division between the Police and the Ministry
of Defence would help ‘in recapturing the imagination of the Police as a
Civilian Force, easily approachable by and comforting to the civilian
population. Not just the Tamil minorities, but even the Sinhala
population in the run-up to the JVP insurgencies had felt alienated from
and by the Police, for possibly no fault of theirs’.
Police Force, guardians of the law |
Reconciliation meetings
That last phrase is characteristic, because this is a balanced
writer. However experience on the ground – which sadly I think only I
possess as someone who has been visiting the North regularly over the
last four years for free discussions with the citizenry in small groups
– would have shown him that the police are now considered eminently
approachable. This is a contrast from the situation not even two years
ago, when several people were wary of the re-establishment of the police
as the main source of security.
Two areas where I have now been at three Reconciliation meetings
illustrate this point. In Puthukudiyirippu, where much needed to be done
in the aftermath of the war, there was universal criticism of the police
about a year back.
However the Inspector General was I think aware of this, and made
some changes, so that last time round there was recognition that things
were better. In January, it seemed that relations were good, and the
requirement that one or two policemen be assigned to each Grama
Niladhari Division was being fulfilled satisfactorily.
I have a simple test to see if this is working, which is to ask Grama
Niladharis the names of ‘their’ policemen. Familiarity in this case
breeds trust, and first name terms generally indicate mutual confidence.
I should note however that there are areas where there are failures for
my test, as in Maritimepattu in the Mullaitivu District where the scheme
is in successful operation only in some GN Divisions.
The explanation for this, provided by a generally positive OIC, was
that the area was vast, and the police allocated to distant areas had
difficulties in travelling. This did not seem to me an acceptable
excuse, but it cannot be rejected out of hand unless the Ministry of
Transport (or the Provincial Ministries) get their act together.
Greater awareness
I am increasingly of the view however that that is a vain hope,
because Central or Provincial control of Transport is a recipe for
disaster. Until we get more practical about such matters, as far as the
police is concerned, the answer is the opening up of more Police posts
with residential facilities in areas too far from the principal
stations.
This has happened in the other area where community relations with
the Police have developed by leaps and bounds since my last visit.
This was Kandaveli, in the Kilinochchi District, where last time the
people had complained about the need to deal with Police in Kilinochchi
for anything serious. There had been a post at Dharmapuram, but that had
generally to refer matters to Headquarters. The OIC seemed to be doing
his best, and was indeed able to provide satisfactory answers to claims
about cattle theft and illicit liquor – though we noted that it would be
useful to keep the community in the picture about court cases that had
been initiated, since without such knowledge the impression was that
nothing had been done about complaints that had been made.
However there was clearly some distance between the Police and the
people, caused largely it seemed by the inadequate facilities at
Dharmapuram.
This had led also to the Police there seeing their primary
obligations as lying elsewhere. However with the station refurbished,
with decent living quarters, and an energetic new OIC who seems to have
implemented thoroughly the requirement for deploying his men in each GN
Division, there was general satisfaction about the services the Police
provided.
I should note however that, while I believe the situation in the
North is very positive as far as the Police are concerned, I cannot say
the same for what happens in the South. Sathiyamoorthy is right to draw
our attention to his element too, but his polite reference to the past
masks the fact that even now there is a sense of alienation from the
Police.
In part this is because the Police in the South have more masters
whom they have to serve, given the various layers of politicians who all
exercise authority with regard to the Police. While obviously one needs
greater awareness about the responses of the public to the Police than I
can provide, given that my mandate is restricted in area, on first
principles one can deduce that the Police have greater difficulties
about working to objective criteria than face them in the North. With
respect to Sathiyamoorthy then, the solution lies in increasing the
professionalism of the Police, not in changing the structures through
which they operate. |