Jilts any notion of freshness
The Proposal:
Ruwini JAYAWARDANA
Choreographer turned director Anne Fletcher’s The Proposal is an
attractive package at first glance but follows the path of a typical
situation in which two lovers are faced in a game of deception.
Manhattan book publisher Margaret Tate is a tyrant who bullies
co-workers, especially her secretary, Andrew, who has to witness
Margaret’s heartless actions and jump to her commands. She goes as far
as blackmailing him into acting like her fiancé to prevent herself being
deported to her native Canada. Gilbertson, who is in charge of the case
warns the couple that if he smells fraud Andrew will be fined and sent
to five years in prison while Margaret will be immediately banished from
the scene. The couple agrees to the terms. The forced romance also
coincides with a major family reunion in Andrew’s home.
Family reunion |
The strength of The Proposal lies in the fact how these two unlikely
candidates would endure each other during the weekend with warm,
friendly country folk from Andrew’s home town, Alaska. Though Andrew was
horrified and unwilling at the beginning he uses the scam as an
opportunity to turn the tables on Margaret by asking her to make him the
editor and accept his book for publication. She reluctantly agrees but
not ending their feud there they exhibit their dislike for each other by
putting their companion in a series of hilariously uncomfortable
positions.
One of the weak points of The Proposal is that some of the jokes are
lewd. For example the scene in which Margaret dances with Andrew’s
grandmother to some upbeat tunes does not fit into the story. The same
goes for the scenes in which Margaret and Andrew ‘bond’ by discovering
similar interests in music. Andrew screeching Rob Base and DJ E-Z Rock’s
duet It Takes Two aloud in a whiny voice does not bring on the intended
laughs.
Similarly the scenes in which Margaret is made to get up on stage and
dance with the locally famous exotic dancer, Ramone, too seem far
fetched. Screenplay writer Pete Chiarelli seems to have taken things too
far in his attempt to add comedy to the rom-com.
Sandra Bullock and Ryan Reynolds as Margaret and
Andrew |
Even the conflict between Andrew and his father seems out of place in
this set up and bores rather than makes the audience perk up. But the
icing on the cake of The Proposal is its utter predictability:
everything that you think is going to happen does happen.
The movie sees Sandra Bullock in a different role, a villainess
turned heroine. She steps into the character of a detested corporate
bigwig in as much ease as she has mastered the role of the goofy and
cute persona that she is known for.
Ryan Reynolds is not convincing as the white knight in shining amour
who rescues Margaret from drowning, Gilbertson and herself. Mary
Steenburgen, Craig T. Nelson, Betty White, Denis O’Hare, Malin Akerman
and Oscar Nuñez make up the rest of the cast of The Proposal.
This could have been a dream run through but not even a gifted
comedienne like Bullock can help the story from falling apart before it
reaches the altar because it lacks heart and humour in crucial instances |