Intellectual Property:
A tool to build sustainable economic growth
Tissa Jayaweera- Chairman, International Chamber of
Commerce
Intellectual Property (IP) continues to be a dynamic and constantly
evolving field, closely tied to technological, economic, political and
social changes. The changing geo-economic landscape has led to a growing
interest in how IP can be used as a tool to build sustainable economic
growth, both in emerging economies looking to build up their economic
base, as well as in more mature economies wanting to maintain their
competitive edge in the global market. Business can play an important
role in helping governments understand the type of IP infrastructure
necessary to stimulate the growth of innovative and creative industries
and to encourage technology transactions. The accelerating pace of
developments in information technology is also having a major impact on
how IP is used, licensed and protected.
Tissa Jayaweera |
The emergence of social media, the increasing prevalence of mobile
devices and applications, ever-increasing bandwidth and changing
consumer behaviour are making IP owners reconsider the strategies and
models for distributing, commercializing and controlling their IP in the
electronic environment. The increased ease of communications and travel
has also led to more cross-border business and IP transactions and
exchange. This brings with it the need for a level playing field and
coherent rules worldwide.
ICC Intellectual Property Roadmap
Current and emerging issues for business and policy-makers highlights
several developments over the past couple of years arising from these
changes. These include the decision to open up the generic Top Level
Domain name space, measures to control copyright and trademark
infringement on the Internet, and efforts to address the high costs and
lengthy proceedings necessary to obtain patents in multiple
jurisdictions (such as more intensive cooperation between patent
offices, further steps in the EU initiative to create a unitary patent
and patent litigation system, and reform bringing the US patent system
one step closer to other patent systems worldwide).
Other developments, with implications for the life sciences, include
the conclusion of the Nagoya Protocol on Access and Benefit Sharing in
relation to genetic resources, and the protection of biosimilar drugs in
the EU and the US.
The ICC 2012 IP Roadmap continues to follow the same structure as in
previous editions. An introductory chapter describing developments with
an impact on IP protection is followed by sections on issues relating to
specific IP rights, on issues common to various IP rights, and on the
interaction between IP and other policy areas. Each section describes
new developments as well as business and government positions and
actions on specific issues. Most sections have been extensively updated
for this new edition, including sections on data exclusivity, plant
variety rights, geographical indications, designs, data bases, valuation
and arbitration and mediation of IP disputes.
This 2012 edition of ICC's flagship intellectual property
publication, ICC IP Roadmap continues to be a useful reference tool for
all those who work in or need to understand intellectual property
policy.
What is intellectual property?
Intellectual property is a creation of the intellect that is owned by
an individual or an organization which can then choose to share it
freely or to control its use in certain ways. Intellectual property is
found almost everywhere, in creative works like books, films, records,
music, art, software, and in everyday objects like cars, computers,
drugs and varieties of plants, all of which has been developed thanks to
advances in science and technology. The distinctive features that help
us choose the products we buy, like brand names and designs, can fall
within the scope of intellectual property. Even the place of origin of a
product can have rights attached to it, as is the case with Champagne
and Gorgonzola.
Much of what we see and use on the Internet, be it a web page or a
domain name, also includes or represents some form of intellectual
property.
Why is intellectual property protected and who benefits?
Through a system of intellectual property rights, it is possible not
only to ensure that an innovation or creation is attributed to its
creator or producer, but also to secure ‘ownership’ of it and benefit
commercially as a result. By protecting intellectual property, society
acknowledges the benefits it contributes and provides an incentive for
people to invest time and resources to foster innovation and expand
knowledge. The intellectual property system is designed to benefit
society as a whole, striking a delicate balance to ensure that the needs
of both the creator and the user are satisfied. Intellectual property
rights usually allow the rights holder to exercise rights over the use
of his or her work for a limited period of time. In return for granting
such rights, society benefits in a number of ways.
The intellectual property system contributes to society by: Enriching
the pool of public knowledge and culture; Maintaining fair competition
and encouraging the production of a wide range of quality goods and
services; Underpinning economic growth and employment; Sustaining
innovation and creation; Promoting technological and cultural advances
and expression.
Where suitable or sufficient intellectual property rights are not
available, or are difficult to enforce, innovators and innovative
enterprises may need to rely to a greater extent on other means to
protect themselves from unfair competition, such as through trade
secrets, contractual agreements, or technical means of preventing
copying. Such means can be less effective in promoting the goals set out
above.
How is intellectual property protected?
In general, intellectual property is protected by giving the creator
of a work or an inventor exclusive rights to commercially exploit his
creation or invention for a limited period of time. These rights can
also be sold, licensed or otherwise disposed of by the rights holder.
Intellectual property rights are granted under the national laws of each
country or region. In addition, various international agreements on
intellectual property rights harmonize laws and procedures, or allow
intellectual property rights to be registered at the same time in
several countries.
Different types of intellectual property, literary and artistic
creations, inventions, brand names, and designs, to name a few are
protected in different ways: Creations in the fields of literature and
the arts, such as books, paintings, music, films and records as well as
software, are generally protected through copyright or so-called related
rights; Technological inventions are typically protected by patents;
Distinctive features such as words, symbols, smells, sounds, colours and
shapes that distinguish one product or service from another, can be
protected by trademark rights; The specific external appearance given to
objects, such as furniture, car body parts, tableware or jewellery, may
enjoy design protection; Geographical indications and trade secrets are
also considered to be types of intellectual property and most countries
provide some form of legal protection for them; Rules to prevent unfair
competition in the commercial world also help protect trade secrets and
other types of intellectual property; Plant varieties are protected
mainly by a specific IP protection regime called plant variety rights,
and may also be protected by patents or by a combination of the two
systems; Specific legal protection is provided in some countries for
integrated circuits and databases.
The same product can also be simultaneously protected by more than
one type of intellectual property right in different countries.
Copyright
Copyright exists to encourage the production of original artistic,
literary and musical creations from books and paintings to movies,
recordings and software. The copyright system rewards artistic
expression by allowing the creator to benefit commercially from his
work. In addition to granting economic rights, copyright also bestows
‘moral’ rights which allow the creator to claim authorship and prevent
mutilation or deformation of his work that might harm his reputation. To
qualify for copyright protection, the work has to be an original
creation and expressed in a certain fixed form. Copyright is
automatically vested in the author once the work is created, though a
few countries maintain registration systems which provide additional
benefits. It can then be licensed or assigned, often to a publisher or a
producer. Copyright protection gives an author exclusive rights of a
certain duration, generally from the time of creation of the work until
fifty or seventy years after the author's death.
Most countries provide similar protection for phonogram producers,
performers and broadcasters. In some countries, performers, producers
and broadcasters of copyrighted works are protected by copyright just
like authors; in other countries, they are instead protected by
neighbouring or related rights. Copyright has become increasingly
important with the development of digital technology and the Internet,
where it is a major form of intellectual property protection for content
distributed online, and where it faces difficult enforcement issues.
Patents
A patent gives the inventor the right, for a specified period of
time, to prevent others from using, making, selling, offering for sale,
or importing his invention without his authorization. In return, the
inventor must disclose the details of his invention in a patent document
that is made publicly available. In this way, patents represent a social
contract between society as a whole and inventors. An innovation which
the inventor prefers to keep secret is known as know-how or a trade
secret. These are protected under different rules. In most countries,
patent protection lasts for 20 years counted from the filing date and is
issued by national or regional government patent offices, to which the
inventor has to submit an application. In order to be granted the
patent, the invention must fulfil three conditions: It must be new: it
should never have been published or publicly used before; It should be
capable of industrial application: It must be something that can be
industrially manufactured or used; It must be ‘non-obvious': it should
not be an invention that would have occurred to any skilled person in
the relevant field.
Patent systems have been adopted by many countries over the years
because: They encourage the disclosure of information to the public,
increasing the public's access to technical and scientific knowledge.
Without the assurance of a patent, an individual or corporate inventor
may choose to keep the details of an invention secret; They provide an
incentive and reward for innovation and investment in R&D and future
inventions; The limited duration of a patent encourages the rapid
commercialization of inventions, so that the public receives a tangible
benefit from the invention sooner rather than later; By encouraging the
publication of details of inventions, patents help avoid duplication of
research and stimulate further research, innovation and competition;
Patents are perceived as a sound intellectual property title, granted in
most territories after a rigorous examination process.
Trademarks
Trademarks allow consumers and businesses to differentiate between
goods and services from different producers, and to select products by
manufacturers whose reputation they trust. For manufacturers or service
providers who have invested the time, effort and money to build up a
good brand image, trademarks are a way to prevent others from unfairly
taking advantage of their reputation. This ensures fair competition
between competitors in the marketplace and encourages producers to
invest in the quality and reputation of their products or services.
Trademark protection can apply to brands, names, signs, symbols, and
even colours, smells, sounds and shapes. In short, almost any
distinctive feature attached to a product or service which distinguishes
it from another can be protected as a trademark. In most countries, a
trademark has to be registered in a national or regional government
trademark office for use with specific goods or services to be
protected. A trademark holder can prevent others from using his
trademark or a similar mark for the same or similar goods or services,
if doing so is likely to cause confusion in the minds of the public. In
many countries, famous or well-known trademarks also enjoy protection
against uses that are considered to disparage, dilute or take unfair
advantage of the reputation of the famous mark.
Almost all businesses, large and small, rely on trademarks.
Trademark protection is used more than any other form of intellectual
property, and in developing as well as developed economies. Trademarks
serve to guarantee origin to local consumers, and readily searchable
trademark registers allow businesses to avoid selecting new marks which
could be confused with existing ones. Several international agreements
on trademark protection exist.
For substantive issues, the most important are the Paris Convention
for the Protection of Industrial Property (1883), the Trademark Law
Treaty (1994), and the TRIPS agreement (1994). The Singapore Treaty on
the Law of Trademarks was adopted on March 28, 2006. For procedural
issues, the main treaties are the Madrid Agreement concerning the
International Registration of Marks (1891) and its Protocol (1989),
using French, English and Spanish as official languages, and the Nice
Agreement concerning the International Classification of Goods and
Services for the Purpose of Registration of Marks (1957).
In Europe, Regulation no 207/09 of February 26, 2009 which codifies
the previous regulation 40/94 on the Community Trade Mark CTM allows a
trademark holder to obtain a single trademark registration covering the
27 European Union Member States. The link made on October 1, 2004
between the CTM and the Madrid Protocol provides trademark owners with
greater flexibility for obtaining international trademark protection.
Further to the study carried in 2010 on the overall trademark system in
the EU, it is likely that amendments will be proposed to the current CTM
Regulation.
Designs
Design rights protect new and original visual aspects of a product or
its packaging. Requirements for protection typically borrow concepts
from both patent law (novelty) and copyright law (originality). The
design eligible for protection must display aesthetic features and must
not be predated by a known overall identical or similar design. Designs
can be expressed in two-dimensional (drawing) or three dimensional
(model) formats. Designs contribute significantly to the marketability
of goods and are crucial assets in several industries, for instance
textiles, fashion, mobile consumer devices, computer software
(interfaces), automobiles and furnishing and decoration.
The regime for design protection differs from one country to another,
although harmonization has been achieved within the European Union, with
Regulation No 6/2002 providing a Community design right effective in all
27 EU Member States. In most countries, design protection is subject to
registration, although there is a trend to extend protection for a short
term to unregistered designs, e.g. for 3 years in the EU. Registered
designs can generally benefit from protection for 25 years. The owner of
a protected design may prohibit the making, selling, importing or
exporting of products incorporating or applying the design. Depending on
the countries, the owner may concurrently avail himself of the
protection of copyright, trademark, and patent law. Design protection is
an area which has benefited lately from significant and promising
harmonization.
Trade secrets
Trade secrets encompass various types of business information,
whether technical, commercial or financial, which is not known or
readily ascertainable by the relevant public and which gives a business
a competitive edge (for instance, manufacturing processes, techniques
and know-how, customers’ lists and profiles, distribution methods,
financial information, ingredients, etc.). In general, information is
eligible for trade secret protection if it is identified, substantial
and secret, as reflected in Article 39 of TRIPS.
Trade secret protection is afforded without registration and can last
without limitation in time, generally so long as confidentiality is
maintained. When the trade secret is patentable know-how, the scope of
legal protection respectively granted by patent law and trade secret
status has to be carefully compared before deciding whether to patent
the invention or to keep it secret. This decision will also depend on
the kind of know-how involved, its contemplated use, the term of the
expected competitive lead and the capability to ensure secrecy in the
long run.
A distinctive feature of a trade secret is the impossibility of
erasing or overriding the effective transfer of knowledge once
disclosed. This is why, when transferring a trade secret, its holder
usually pays great attention to confidentiality provisions and to the
efficiency of interim court injunctions that can be obtained locally to
prevent unauthorized dissemination. Businesses, having become more aware
of the value of trade secrets, confidentiality and nondisclosure
agreements, and non-compete agreements in employment contracts, now use
them widely in the course of business dealings as well as in the context
of employment relationships in an attempt to limit unwanted leaks and
uses of valuable business information.
However, trade secret protection remains weak in many countries, due
partly to the lack of specific protective legislation and partly to the
lack of awareness by the judiciary and other administrative bodies.
Sanctions against procurement, use or disclosure of a trade secret,
through application of the laws on unfair competition or practices a
branch of tort law are also provided by Article 39 of TRIPS. Violation
of a confidentiality undertaking can also be treated as a breach of
contract. In limited cases, misappropriation of trade secrets can be a
criminal offence such as theft or business espionage. Communication of
know-how as such, or as part of mixed patent and know-how licence
agreements, is a well-known way of exploiting trade secrets of a
technical nature, which are now less hindered by national restrictions
affecting cross-border transfer of know-how.
Domain names
An Internet domain name is a unique Internet address in a simplified
form, designed to enable users to localize and visit a website on the
Internet in an easy manner or use e-mail. Each computer (‘server’) has a
fixed or dynamic Internet Protocol address (‘IP Address’), which enables
it to communicate with Internet resources during a specific session. A
domain name is nothing else than the easy to remember translation of
such an IP address. For example, the Internet domain name iccwbo.org
contains ‘iccwbo’ as the ‘second level domain’ before the dot and ‘org’
as the ‘Top Level Domain’ after the dot. There are generic TLDs (org,
com, edu, etc.) and country code TLDs.
Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers ICANN is the
global entity that is responsible for the coordination and management of
the Domain Name System. With the explosive growth of the Internet,
domain names have become valuable assets to businesses serving as
business identifiers that may conflict with already existing business
identifiers (e.g. trademarks, geographical indications, trade names,
etc.). Through domain names, businesses can establish Internet presence
and attract Internet users worldwide. When building upon strong
trademarks, businesses seek to register and use the domain names
identical to or incorporating their trademarks under Top Level Domains
relevant to their businesses. Problems may occur when domain names
incorporating trademarks or variations thereto are registered by others,
including by cyber squatters. |