Ambassador Aryasinha intervenes at screening of film
at EU Parliament:
‘Film a gross distortion of fact’
The following is the text of the
intervention by Ravinatha Aryasinha, Ambassador of Sri Lanka to Belgium,
Luxembourg and the EU at the screening of ‘Sri Lanka’s Killing Fields’
at the European Parliament on October 12.
“The government of Sri Lanka strongly protests the use of the
premises of the European Parliament, through a private members
initiative, for the screening of this film.
Ravinatha Aryasinha |
“Upon receiving information of this insidious agenda, on October 3, I
drew this matter to the attention of Dr Jerzy Buzek, President of the
European Parliament. On October 7, in a reply on behalf of President
Buzek, Ms Inga Rosinska, Head of Cabinet of the President assured me,
that “similar to many other events organized on the Parliament’s
premises, this film screening is not organized by an official political
organ of the European Parliament, therefore it does not represent or
reflect an official position of the institution or any of its bodies.”
“My presence here today, is to underline the partiality of these
proceedings and to counter the gross distortion of fact ‘Sri Lanka’s
Killing Fields’ seeks to convey.
“Let me in brief spell out why we object to the screening of this
film.
First, this film’s authenticity is in question, as it includes
footage of dubious origin, content that is distorted and without proper
sourcing, and makes unsubstantiated allegations against the government
of Sri Lanka.
Aired and shown without any guarantee, this film has the potential to
incite hatred amongst different communities in Sri Lanka, including
future generations, and adversely affects the ongoing reconciliation
process.
The Government of Sri Lanka is in possession of substantial evidence
to prove that most of the footage in the film has been stage managed and
doctored, and has made arrangements to make this information available
to the UN Secretary General and the authorities concerned through
appropriate channels.
“Its star witness and chief protagonist Damilvany Gnanakumar
portrayed as a UK citizen who went to Sri Lanka and got held up due to
the fighting and who served as a medical volunteer, is now proved to be
a member of the LTTE ‘Soodiya’ Regiment and a prominent member of the
Tamil Youth Organization (TYO), who unknown to her family went back to
Sri Lanka to help ‘Castro’, the LTTE’s point person responsible for
coordinating its international network.
“Another prominent contributor to this doctored narrative Gorden
Weisss, the former spokesperson of the UN in Sri Lanka, in this film
claims that between 10,000 to 40,000 civilians were killed, while his
original estimate when in Colombo was 7,000, which was refuted the very
next day by the U.N. itself as unreliable.
Another prominent personality referred to in the film -Ms. Isipriya
who is portrayed as a ‘TV announcer’, is a trained LTTE cadre holding
the rank of Lt Colonel, and was responsible for the training of LTTE
female suicide cadres.
The doctored footage depicting shooting at point blank range,
originally claimed to have been recorded from a mobile phone, has now
been proved to have been done from a hand held camera which has a date
mark 15 July 2009 at UTC 13:17:23, almost three months after the ending
of the terrorist conflict on 19 May 2009. This, together with other
anomalies in the synchronization of the audio and video of this film,
lends credence that the whole episode was stage managed.
“The film also fails to name their sources and uses shadows and
ghosts in their interviews, thereby further questioning its authenticity
and denying any objective viewer the possibility of verifying the
information presented.
“Translations at critical points of the film are also consciously
distorted to mislead the viewer, such as the point at which civilians
are seen being huddled into a trench, seemingly to protect themselves
against shelling. However, the comments by the people correctly
translated, merely denote their asking not to be filmed, again re-emphasising
the stage managed nature of this film.
“Even something as simple as a civilian protest, which is described
as a “spontaneous” move in the film, has now been proved to have been
stage managed by the LTTE. “The charge that hospitals were attacked by
the Sri Lankan forces during the fighting, has been disputed by medical
doctors who served in those very hospitals at the time. “The accusation
that GOSL denied food and medicine, and deliberately targeted civilians
in the ‘no-fire’ zone is completely without basis, and runs contrary to
the massive humanitarian operation known to have been carried out by the
Sri Lankan security forces, who in the final stages of the conflict, at
great risk to themselves, brought back to safety nearly 300,000
civilians including women and children, held as human shields by the
LTTE for over a year.
“We have also made available to you at this venue copies of ‘Lies
Agreed Upon’, a video documentary, and the report titled ‘Humanitarian
Operation: Factual Analysis’, produced by the Government of Sri Lanka.
The first provides a point by point response to the allegations made in
the film ‘Sri Lanka’s Killing Fields’, while the latter details the
various stages of the humanitarian operation. I trust that after
perusing this material, you will be better informed about the facts in
this case, which would help you separate the truth from the propaganda.
Political leadership
“Second, this film seeks to downplay the immense suffering caused to
the people of Sri Lanka for nearly 30 years, predominantly the Tamil
community, by the LTTE, an entity proscribed as a terrorist organization
by the EU.
“The LTTE is responsible for the killing of a generation of Sri
Lanka’s political leadership of all ethnic groups. It included a sitting
President, a Foreign Minister and a Leader of the Opposition, as well as
a former Prime Minister of India. Civilian massacres, suicide bombings
and acts of ethnic cleansing were integral parts of the LTTE’s pursuit
to create a fascist, mono-ethnic Tamil Eelam. Even Mr Anders Behring
Brevik, the person who was responsible for the recent terror attacks in
Norway, has claimed in his writings, that he closely followed the terror
tactics of the LTTE and endorsed them.
“It is ironic, that since the LTTE leadership was militarily defeated
on 19 May 2009, while in Sri Lanka there has been no cause for any
counter terrorism action, that in counter-terror operations across
Europe, some 32 LTTE activists have been arrested, while an additional
21 have been convicted over the last two years. In the trial of 5 LTTE
members presently taking place in the Netherlands, the Public
Prosecutor’s Office is calling for 16 year jail sentences, which
indicates the seriousness of their criminal activities on European soil.
“Third, the motive of the producers and promoters of this film, is to
discredit and vilify Sri Lanka and to detract attention from the
considerable positive developments that have taken place on the ground
since the ending of terrorism a little over 2 years ago. It shows patent
bias in ignoring Sri Lanka’s acclaimed success story of managing the
post-conflict recovery, which compares well with post-conflict
situations elsewhere, including in Europe. These developments have been
acknowledged by numerous visiting foreign delegations to the country,
including the South Asia Delegation, the formal body of the European
Parliament which follows developments in Sri Lanka, and whose members
visited Sri Lanka earlier this year and submitted their report in June
2011.
“The socio-economic, nutritional, and mortality indicators in the IDP
centres housing the displaced were deemed commendable by international
standards, to that of a normal population of this magnitude. Over 65
international and local NGOs operated freely in these centres. As per
the Situation Report of the Ministry of Resettlement, as of 19 September
2011 there are only 7439 IDPs remaining and the main IDP site at Manik
Farm is shortly to be closed.
Ex-combatants
“Of the 11,955 ex-combatants who surrendered or were arrested at the
end of the terrorist conflict, a total of 9962 have been rehabilitated
and re-intergraded into society. This includes all 594 ex-child
combatants, who have been handed over to their parents. Of the
remainder, some are to be prosecuted, while the rest would be released
in staggered intervals after they complete their rehabilitation
programme, depending on their degree of terrorist involvement.
“Within a period of 21 months GOSL has also de-mined approximately
92% (1.2 million sq. mt. out of a total 1.3 million sq. mt), of the
contaminated areas of LTTE mine fields, thankfully recording not a
single death among the returning civilians due to landmines. Arms caches
of the LTTE continue to be discovered during the on-going de-mining
process.
“The northern province where the LTTE had prevented any development
work for almost 30 years, is now seeing massive government investment
into infrastructure development, improvement of education, cultural and
livelihood development activities. In 2010, the economic growth recorded
in the northern province was 22%, and the revival of the economy has
enhanced incomes and improved livelihoods.
“Since May 2009, the people of these areas have also actively
participated in the Presidential, Parliamentary and Local Government
electoral processes, exercising their franchise and joining the
democratic process after a lapse of many decades.
Reconciliation
“Within months after the ending of terrorism, in a spirit of
reconciliation the Government of Sri Lanka commenced a political
dialogue with the Tamil National Alliance (TNA), the largest Tamil
political party represented in Parliament, and subsequently appointed a
Parliamentary Select Committee for a national-level discourse focusing
on constitutional reforms.
“One of the most important actions taken post-conflict, was the
appointment by President Mahinda Rajapaksa of the Lessons Learnt and
Reconciliation Commission (LLRC) - the domestic process premised on the
concept of restorative justice, presently underway to ensure
accountability, justice and reconciliation in Sri Lanka. The LLRC which
began sittings on 11 August 2010, has in response to a public notice
received 266 written representations and had 204 persons (including
those invited by the Commission) providing oral submissions during
sittings held in Colombo.
Additionally, sessions have also been held in the districts of Jaffna,
Mullaitivu, Killinochchi, Mannar, Vavunia, Trincomalee, Batticaloa,
Ampara, Puttalam, as well as at the Boosa detention centre in the Galle
district where the ex-combatants are being held in detention. In these
field visits the LLRC has heard oral submissions from 735 persons, and
received written representations from around 5000 persons. In September
2010, it submitted interim recommendations which covered issues relating
to detention of ex-combatants, land issues, law and order,
administration and language issues, socio-economic and livelihood
issues. The Government of Sri Lanka has made clear that once the final
report of the LLRC is released by 15 November 2011, it will take
appropriate action on its recommendations.
“Fourth, the timing of this event is particularly sinister, coming on
the eve of the presentation of the LLRC Report due next month. It would
appear that the three organizations sponsoring this event, and the
forces behind them, are intent on pre-judging and discrediting the LLRC
report even before it is released. It is not a surprise that AI, HRW and
ICG should do so, having refused an earlier invitation from the LLRC to
testify before the Commission. The same applies to Mr Callum Macrae, the
Director/Producer of ‘Sri Lanka’s Killing Fields’, who together with
Channel 4 which aired the film, turned down repeated calls by the LLRC,
to provide the original video and any other evidence available, so that
the LLRC could investigate. I believe the lesson to be drawn from this
is that it is probably easier to cast aspersions from afar and keep the
pot boiling, than having such allegations put to test.
“The indecent hurry to host events like this and to call for
international inquiries, is probably due to their fear that once the
LLRC report comes out, they will be short of one further excuse, with
which to continue their obsessive attack on the Government of Sri Lanka
- for eliminating the LTTE and having denied them the main weapon used
by external sources inimical to Sri Lanka’s interest, to undermine the
country and prevent it reaching it full potential.
“Fifth, this event is also a reminder that the Director/Producer of
this film and INGOs such as AI, HRW and ICG, are driven by the
compulsions of certain interested elements of the Sri Lankan Tamil
expatriates who have become vote banks and pressure groups in several
Western countries. We must seriously ponder the question, as to who
speaks for the Sri Lankan Tamil community?. Whether it is the self
seeking vociferous minority living in greener pastures overseas who
continue to advocate mono-ethnic separatism in Sri Lanka, while
espousing the ideology of the LTTE, using its resources and being
manipulated by its surviving military leaders; or whether it is the
Tamil community living in the North and the East and other parts of Sri
Lanka who were subjected to decades of violence, who together with the
enlightened sections of the Sri Lankan Tamil expatriates are keen to
re-build their own future and that of their children in a new and
peaceful Sri Lanka, in a spirit of reconciliation.
“It is in the above context, that those MEPs responsible for
facilitating this private event, and in allowing the European Parliament
to be used as a platform by LTTE apologists, should re-think their
actions. What you are probably unaware of, is that your support to
initiatives such as these only serve to strengthen the rump elements of
the LTTE seeking refuge in the West, who use the propaganda value
derived from the screening of this film, as a tool to intensify their
fund-raising and recruitment activities, thereby undermining the process
of reconciliation in Sri Lanka.
“It is important that European States and institutions, that stand
for the ideals of freedom and democracy should not be fooled by the
false pretences of those elements behind such exercises, and do not
provide any political or symbolic support to the subterranean agenda of
LTTE apologists.” |