Professionals heading to India
Economy attracting Western workers:
Historically, India has been a society with a surplus of labour,
accustomed to exporting skilled as well as unskilled workers abroad.
The Mumbai city |
Indian governments have therefore traditionally favoured liberal
migration rules and paid only limited attention to regulating
immigration-outside the context of specific concerns over terrorism and
cross-border flows from Bangladesh.
However, recent events suggest that the role of foreign labour in
India is changing:
In May 2009 violence broke out between villagers and a group of 600
Chinese workers at a steel plant in Jharkand state. Enquiries revealed
that there were up to 30,000 Chinese employed on 14 separate power
projects across India, mostly without appropriate visas.
The government reacted with moves to tighten visa requirements.
Yet this in turn brought widespread protests from Indian companies,
which were concerned to protect their freedom to employ skilled
expatriates.
The controversy highlighted both Indian companies' growing interest
in hiring high-level talent from abroad-particularly from Western
countries-and the government's sluggish appreciation of this trend.
Demand for talent. Hospitality, tourism and aviation have a long
history of hiring expatriate professionals for key posts in India.
More recently, firms in other sectors-including information
technology (IT), banking, pharmaceutical, electronics, health care,
aerospace, nuclear energy and education-have looked to do the same:
A recent study estimated that there are 40,000 expatriate workers
registered as employed within Indian firms, 15 percent of whom occupy
leadership roles.
Expatriate managers are seen as more willing to take risks, to
innovate and to promote transparency and accountability. -Foreign
recruits and Indian employees learn from each other, helping make
business culture more global.
Outsourcer strategies. Indian firms providing outsourcing services
have their own reasons for turning to high-level expatriate
professionals.
They tend to struggle to win complex and high-end consulting jobs.
One way to compete is to bring in expatriate expertise that helps build
the close-to-client presence required by advanced IT consulting.
Although hiring foreign workers reduces the cost advantages India has
traditionally enjoyed, firms increasingly see it as necessary if they
wish to be global players. Their hiring practices complement these
trends.
Destination India. Equally strong influences are drawing Western
professionals, both at younger and more senior levels, to opportunities
in India:
For new graduates, Indian internships offer valuable exposure to an
Asian business environment.
For young professionals, international exposure and a global skill
set can be vital components of an effective resume.
For more senior professionals, many firms now offer pay packages that
are competitive with those in the United States, which buy an elite
lifestyle in the Indian setting.
Challenges. The employment of expatriates presents a range of
significant challenges in the Indian environment. Not the least of these
is Indian bureaucracy and political interference in the labour market:
Following the controversy over Chinese workers, the government in
October announced a crackdown on foreign workers, limiting these to
technical experts and senior managers, with a stipulation that foreign
nationals could comprise no more than one percent of a firm's workforce.
December saw a further amendment of the rules to create a new type of
"P" visa for expatriates working on specified projects, with a maximum
of 40 per project.
It is clear that the government recognizes the value of expatriate
workers, but has to balance this against the political penalties of
being seen, however theoretically, to be giving "Indian" jobs to
foreigners.
Outlook. India's small but significant move toward the employment of
skilled expatriate workers is a reversal of the long-standing "brain
drain" of Indian talent to the United States and Europe. It represents
the growing maturity of India's globalization.
So far, Indian firms and cities have been able to accommodate these
new affluent professionals, although political interference and
bureaucratic changes will remain a problem. Forbes |