Saving civilians from Tigers and Crocodile Tears
The last week has seen what amount to pleas to save the Liberation
Tigers of Tamil Eelam reach hysterical levels. Whilst much of this was
couched initially in language suggesting concern not for the Tigers, but
for the civilians trapped by the Tigers, gradually the mask slipped, and
the true colours of the interventionists showed themselves.
The picture became clear when the Sri Lankan Government granted a
humanitarian pause which had been argued for on the grounds that this
was essential for the captive civilians to escape. There was no actual
argument for this, since a pause is needed when something has to be
stopped, and there was no need to stop the Sri Lankan forces from firing
on civilians fleeing to refuge amongst them. They had never even started
this, and in the entire history previously of 65,000 finding their way
to safety with the government, there was not a single allegation even of
harm coming to them from our forces, even by accident.
All the shooting and killing of these escapees was by the LTTE and
therefore the plea to stop firing should have been made to them. But no,
ulterior motives held sway here, and so the call had to be to the
government.
And then, when the government obliged, the hidden motives became
clear. Instead of concerted pleas to the LTTE to honour the pause and
let their captives free, immediately the cry was that the pause was not
long enough, and that it had to be extended. Mr. Miliband, with his
hockey sticks attitude to life, even went on and on about a ceasefire,
as was demanded by the motley crew of Tiger sympathizers who seem to
have taken over the soul of the Labour Party.
The claim was that two days was not enough. If common sense did not
make it clear that this was nonsense, yesterday's events, when almost
40,000 victims of the Tigers poured out in a day, would have given Mr.
Miliband and his cohorts the lie. But will there be an apology or even a
retraction. Certainly not. How can a pillar of the Foreign Office be
wrong, and mere darkies on the ground right about matters in their own
country?
Meanwhile the method in which the hostages were freed also shows that
the arguments of the Tigers and their voluntary and involuntary
supporters were all wrong. Weeks of pleas and then the pauses led only
to greater Tiger intransigence.
Contrariwise, carefully targeted operations that spared civilians and
involved only minimal collateral damage succeeded.
So Gareth Evans will shower the UN Security Council with missiles,
Dave Miliband will launch Des Browne at New York with Simon Hughes to
inflict collateral damage, Human Rights Watch will drag Amnesty
International in its wake as it tries to torpedo the advancing forces as
well as the fleeing civilians - and Nimalka Fernando will dance round
Geneva urging all and sundry to snap at our heels.
Nothing will change, except that the UN at last, helped by genuine
experts on such situations as the Special Representative on the Human
Rights of the displaced, seems to be trying to move forward instead of
allowing itself to be tied up in the bonds of Tigers and their
apologists.
|