End of textile quota may leave poorer countries hanging by thread
The Washington Diplomat - A Hong Kong apparel company with a
manufacturing plant in Mauritius is returning to China after 30 years in
the tiny African island nation, putting 6,000 employees out of work.
Since 2003, Mauritius has lost some 20,000 apparel jobs,
a trend exacerbated by the termination on Jan. 1, 2005, of all global
textile and apparel quotas.
In place since the early 1970s, the quotas, collectively
known as the Multifiber Agreement (MFA), primarily served to limit the
volume of exports to protect the domestic industries of the importing
country.
U.S. textiles and apparel companies in particular feared
increased competition from abroad, but the quotas have, turned out to
benefit nations with large, unskilled workforces, acting almost like an
affirmative action program for poorer nations.
The elimination of the quotas for all categories of
textiles and apparel culminates a 10-year phase out established by the
General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade talks of 1992-94, known as the
Uruguay Round.
The phase-out program began in 1995 under the World
Trade Organisation (WTO). In international trade lingo, the end of
quotas is known as the post-MFA period.
Ironically, the countries that led the drive to end
quotas now may suffer the most. These include Indonesia, Pakistan,
Bangladesh, Colombia and others whose economies are heavily based on
textile exports.
It was anticipated that without quotas, these nations
would have greater access to the U.S. and European markets for their
exports. But at the time, China was little more than a speck on the
horizon.
Today, because of its ability to under price its
competitors, China is becoming the dominant global exporter of textiles
and apparel, threatening to severely disrupt, if not wipe out, the
textile sector of many emerging world nations, such as Mauritius.
The impact of the end of the quotas was felt in Sri
Lanka even before the final termination date. Sri Lanka's apparel
industry is the nation's largest, directly or indirectly employing some
one million workers.
In factories that New York Times columnist Thomas
Friedman has called "so clean you can eat off them," a highly skilled
and educated workforce produces high-end lingerie for world-class
labels, including Victoria's Secret.
Sri Lanka also specialises in outerwear and sportswear
in an industry that has become vertically integrated, from the
production of fabric all the way to the end product.
Working conditions and benefits for workers are the envy
of the rest of the world, and industrial facilities are well integrated
with schools, parks, transportation and other elements of the community.
Given the high quality of its products and the
sophistication of its manufacturing and corporate structures, it is not
surprising that the Sri Lankan textile and apparel industry has been
thriving since the early 1980s, and the quotas have been a driving force
in this spectacular growth, according to Sri Lankan Ambassador Devinda
Subasinghe.
"The quotas allowed us to grow by guaranteeing access to
world markets," said Subasinghe. As to the impact of the quota
termination, "The jury is still out," but he said the textile and
apparel industry "is very, very concerned" about the dramatic increase
in Chinese exports, particularly since 2001.
For instance, Chinese exports in man-made fiber bras
increased 18 times between 2001 and 2004, according to the U.S.
Department of Commerce's Office of Textiles and Apparel.
So what's the answer? "The solution is to level the
playing field and continue to ensure access to the world markets by all
apparel exporting nations," Subasinghe said. Unlike China and other
large exporting nations, Sri Lanka has a market economy and the national
government has very few options to prop up its private industries.
"We are also reviewing options with the United States to
reduce the $250 million we pay in tariffs," explained Subasinghe. "These
tariffs increase our costs by 16 percent and are considerably higher
than those imposed on some other nations." |