Blair's Govt slammed over Human Rights Act
BRITAIN: An influential committee of British parliamentarians
slammed Prime Minister Tony Blair's government, accusing ministers of
blaming the Human Rights Act for their own failings.
A report by the cross-party Joint Committee on Human Rights said
ministers including Blair himself had made "unfounded claims" about the
act, which his government introduced six years ago, and had used it as a
scapegoat for administrative mistakes.
The act was implemented in 2000, making rights from the European
Convention enforceable in British courts.
However it has been blamed in a string of cases where the rights of
offenders have been widely judged to have taken precedence over those of
society, prompting calls for the law to be amended or even repealed.
"We are extremely concerned that the Human Rights Act has been
getting the blame for ministerial or administrative failings when it has
nothing to do with these failings," said committee chairman Andrew
Dismore.
The committee said it had examined three cases this year where Blair
or his ministers had given the impression that the act, or its
interpretation, was protecting criminals or terrorism suspects at the
expense of the law-abiding public.
In May, a top judge ruled that nine Afghans who hijacked a plane
after it left Afghanistan's capital Kabul and ordered the pilot to fly
to London could not be deported under human rights laws because their
lives would be at risk.
Blair described the decision as an "abuse of common sense".
Another case related to a violent sex attacker who murdered a woman
after being freed from jail. The Chief Inspector of Probation said he
should never have been released and too much attention had been paid to
his human rights. The other related to the failure to deport foreign
prisoners at the end of their jail term, a scandal in which about 1,000
ex-convicts were allowed to stay in Britain when they should have been
returned to their home country.
"In our view, none of the three cases which sparked controversy ...
demonstrates a clear need to consider amending the Human Rights Act,"
the committee's report said.
The act has come in for much criticism from Blair's Labour party and
the opposition Conservatives amid a background of public concern that
the judicial system is too soft on serious criminals.
Conservative leader David Cameron said in June the law should be
replaced with a British Bill of Rights, saying Blair was to blame for
bringing in an act that made the fight against terrorism and crime
harder.
London, Tuesday, Reuters. |