SAARC in the third
cycle:
'Make it functional and effective'
by Syed Muazzem Ali
The twice-postponed thirteenth Summit of South Asian Association for
Regional Cooperation (SAARC) will be held in Dhaka on November 12-13,
2005. There were some uncertainties about holding of the Summit on these
dates in view of the recent devastating earthquakes in Pakistan and
India.
SAARC heads at the 12th summit |
The confusion seems to be over as spokespersons of both these
seriously affected countries have now made statements expressing their
support for the holding of the SAARC Summit in Dhaka on the scheduled
dates.
It may be recalled that the thirteenth Summit was originally
scheduled to be held in early January this year. It was postponed the
first time because of the tragic tsunami that had seriously affected
three SAARC members while important political developments in Nepal and
the security situation in Bangladesh led to the second postponement.
The forthcoming Summit in Dhaka will mark the beginning of the third
cycle. In order to make SAARC more functional and effective it is
necessary at this juncture to re-evaluate the existing practices.
When SAARC was launched in 1985, the Summit was envisaged as a
functional regional organisation to hasten the process of development
and alleviate the poverty through regional cooperation. Unfortunately,
instead of functional meetings these Summits have turned into ceremonial
meetings with huge fanfare at a tremendous cost to the public exchequer.
The SAARC Summits became such an elaborate extravaganza that one of
its members, Bhutan, has been unable to host any Summit because of
limited infrastructure. A veteran South Asian diplomat had once
commented to me, "Whom are we trying to impress? Don't we know how poor
we all are?" After all, 40 per cent of the world's absolute poor live in
South Asia. Enough fanfare has been done during the past two decades; it
is time to cut down all unnecessary expenses and make SAARC Summits more
functional and efficient.
Incidentally, the richest countries of the world that are members of
Group of Eight (G-8) or the European Union (EU) hold highly functional
Summits without any fanfare. Their Summit meetings are short and
professional, and their leaders come with small delegations and spend
the entire time under one roof.
The other objective should be to make the Summit proceedings short.
The existing practice of weeklong preparatory meetings at various levels
should be dispensed with. The Meetings of the Programming Committee of
Senior Officers and of the Standing Committee of Foreign Secretaries
should be held well before the Summit. Like OIC, NAM and Commonwealth
and other Summits, the only preparatory meeting to the SAARC Summit
should be a one-day Meeting of Foreign Ministers to finalise the agenda.
In the past two decades, despite its tremendous potentials, SAARC has
produced few tangible results and has generally been ignored in the
international circles. How do we reverse this trend and make SAARC
effective? Well, the first requirement is renewed commitment of all
members to the cause of regional cooperation.
We must say what we mean, and mean what we say. Otherwise, we will
continue to issue declarations and sign agreements without working for
their implementation.
In the past, each member attached priority to those issues, which
were of particular interest to them and ignored their obligations on
other issues. Such selective prioritisation has not promoted the cause
of regional cooperation.
Furthermore, conflicts and tensions between two South Asian nuclear
powers and archrivals, India and Pakistan, have very often hindered
progress in SAARC. However, there are now visible signs of improvement
of relations between the two countries, and it should be in the
collective interest of all members to vigorously push forward the cause
of regional cooperation. Enough agreements have been signed and
declarations made during the past decades and it is now time to work for
their implementation.
As the host and the prime initiator of the proposal, Bangladesh has a
special responsibility to give fresh momentum to the SAARC in the third
cycle. Our basic objective should be not to hold the Summit for the sake
of holding it or to take over its rotating Chairmanship, but to take
stock of the situation and chart out a new plan of action for the coming
decade.
Trade, economic cooperation, and poverty alleviation are the core
issues in the SAARC. At the last Summit in Islamabad there was a
milestone agreement among the members to elevate SAARC from SAPTA (South
Asian Preferential Trade Arrangement) to SAFTA (South Asian Free Trading
Area) and it was agreed that SAFTA would enter into force from January
2006. To that end, some meetings of trade officials were held to
exchange export lists and to work out details.
The SAARC Commerce Ministers were scheduled to meet in Islamabad on
18-19 October 2005 but unfortunately, due to earthquakes, the meeting
had to be postponed. The Dhaka Summit should give a clear directive so
that SAFTA could be launched from next January as scheduled.
The basic aim of SAFTA is to broaden economic cooperation, ensure
equitable distribution of benefits of trade and to cater to the special
needs of the small and Least Developed Countries (LDCs) by providing
them with preferential treatment.
The ultimate objective is to create SAEU (South Asian Economic Union)
in line with what has been achieved by the European Union. To that end,
the last Summit had taken important decisions for accelerated and
balanced economic growth through strengthening transportation, transit
and communication links across the region.
Likewise, it had directed the working group on energy to undertake a
study on South Asian Energy Cooperation including the concept of an
energy ring. In this era of high oil prices and rising demands of South
Asian countries, a collaborative effort is urgently needed.
Another important achievement of the last summit was the signing of
the Social Charter with a view to addressing important social issues
such as population, stabilisation, youth mobilisation, women
empowerment, human resource development, promotion of health and
nutrition, and protection of children.
These are key issues for the welfare and well being of all South
Asians. The UN Human Development Report has once again put the South
Asian countries at the bottom rung of the table and it should be in the
common interest of all members to accelerate the process of human
development in the region.
At the Islamabad Summit the South Asian leaders had rightly
recognised "poverty alleviation as the greatest challenge facing the
people of South Asia" and had declared poverty alleviation "as the
overreaching goal of all SAARC activities" The Summit had directed the
reconstituted Independent South Asian Commission on Poverty Alleviation
(ISACPA) to submit to Dhaka Summit a comprehensive and realistic blue
print setting out SAARC Development Goals for the next five years in the
areas of poverty alleviation, education, health and environment. Despite
recent GDP growth, 43 percent of South Asians still live below the
poverty line and hence this issue must be given further momentum at the
Dhaka Summit.
The last Summit had also emphasised the need for undertaking and
reinforcing regional cooperation in the conservation of water resources,
protection of environment, pollution control and to disaster
preparations to face natural calamities.
The recent earthquakes and the earlier tsunami have seriously
affected a number of South Asian countries. These disasters have once
again underlined the need for the effective implementation of the SAARC
Plan of Action on environment. The longer-term objective is to draft a
Regional Environment Treaty.
Furthermore, the Summit had taken important decisions to combat
terrorism and to strengthen cooperation in information and
communications, agriculture, food reserve, cultural, and health areas
especially to effectively control tuberculosis, HIV/AIDS and other
deadly diseases.
Turning to organisational issues, according to some reports,
Afghanistan had expressed interest to join SAARC as a member and China
has also shown interest to be associated with SAARC activities in some
capacity. Since there is no provision for inclusion of new members in
the SAARC charter, no action could be taken in this regard.
Expansion of membership is a sure sign of vitality of a regional
organisation. ASEAN, EU and, for that matter, most regional
organisations have over the period of years expanded their membership.
Likewise, SAARC should set clear criteria for inclusion of new members
and observers, and consider all such requests objectively.
Given these broad parameters, the Dhaka Summit has to take effective
actions for the early implementation of these important decisions and to
give new momentum to the moribund regional organisation.
During my assignment in Paris, I had appreciated how patiently and
meticulously our European Union colleagues have built their regional
organisation virtually on the ruins of Second World War.
Their examples should inspire us to strengthen our regional
organisation for the benefit of South Asians who constitute quarter of
humanity.
(Syed Muazzem Ali is a former Foreign Secretary)
Courtesy 'Daily Star' |